Driving and Cellphones
There is a reason why talking on a cellphone while driving is illegal in Ontario, and I just got to witness it first-hand, as I do many times a week now that I'm unemployed and walk the kids back-and-forth to school a lot. There is one set of lights on their walk to school, and we were waiting at it about 10 minutes ago waiting for the crossing light to go green. I noticed the signal for the cars went yellow, then red. A guy in a crossover stationwagon / minivan with cellphone clearly held up to his left ear with his left hand, initially stops at the red light as I enter the crosswalk with my kids, but then calmly proceeds through it!
Lucky for him he was on the far side of the street driving from my right to my left. Had he been on my side, he'd have gotten a swift boot to the side-panel with my steel toed shoes. Lucky for me I noticed that he pulled in to the side of the road just beyond the intersection, so I walked over and tapped on his passenger window. He was still jabbering away on his cell phone - I guess in a way it was a good thing that he seemed to recognize that he should pull over to talk. I very calmly said to him "You know you just went through a red light, while talking on a cell phone. Both of which are illegal in Ontario". "What red light?" he replied with, just as calmly. "The one right back there that you just went through, while talking on a cell phone, both of which are illegal in Ontario." Then I motioned to my boys who were back about 10 feet where I told them to stand and said "And you cut off my kids in the crosswalk in the process".
Fortunately he was one of the 90% or more of people who when caught red handed are willing to own up to it and apologize. Lucky for me only a small percentage of people get obstinate and irate when caught red-handed.
Coincidentally, a few days ago a friend was conducting an informal poll on her blog, asking whether this-or-that were rude to do with a cell phone when you were with someone else. She listed a whole range of activities and asked for people's opinions on them. I do a lot of thinking about cell phones - I don't have one, and I don't really want want. And they are a bit of a pet peeve for me for a number of different reasons, not the least of which being that most people throw theirs away every year or two and get a new model. For me they are a symbol of consumer culture at its worst. But I realised after reading this informal poll, that another reason I pick on cell phones is that even the nicest people can become completely different people when using them.
I answered my friend's poll with the explanation that I think cell phones to some degree pre-select for rudeness. I said it was like looking for alcoholics - sure you can find them at the supermarket, but you are a lot more likely to find them at the liquor store. Cell phones are by definition bought by people who have a degree of self-importance to them. And by definition, self-important people can be rude. How can I make such an audacious claim? Hear me out.
Generally speaking, people buy cell phones because they think they need to be reachable at every waking moment of the day. And precious few people who have them, really-and-truly need them. I certainly don't think I am important enough to need to be reachable at every waking moment, so I therefore feel safe in my claim that people who own cellphones do think they are. You buy it because you think you need to answer it when it rings. And like Pavlov's dog, the salivation begins as soon as it does ring, and simply by reflex whether driving a car or having a real-life conversation with a dear friend, that ring must be answered this instant! Not true, you say? I say that someone would be pretty foolish to buy a cell phone if they did not intend to answer it when it rang, would they not? So by definition, generally speaking, people with cell phones are going to be rude with them. Of course, not all people, all the time. But I'd wager most people, at least some of the time. More than half. And as I just saw a few minutes ago, being rude can lead to downright being dangerous. And that ain't cool, especially not when my kids are in that crosswalk!
In any case, I don't mean to crucify cell phone users. I just mean to offer a different perspective on a part of everyday life that most people take for granted.
Comments
Cell phone ban
edit: never mind.. someone else already posted what I just posted.
Quite the Addiction
Holy cripes. That's quite the addiction. Bus drivers should be fired for simply having a cell phone on their person.
http://www.cbc.ca/world/story/2009/05/09/boston-trolley-crash.html
"Transit officials in Boston say an underground crash of commuter trolleys was caused by one driver text messaging. [...] The 24-year-old driver was texting his girlfriend, according to the Boston Globe newspaper."
It is a law now
Here is a story on the CBC website
So I was a few days ahead..
So I was a few days ahead.. not being enforced yet but it is coming!
Clarification
Just to be clear.. Ontario has introduced Legislation to ban the use of cell phones while driving The Star Article but it is not currently illegal to do so. It is illegal in quebec CBC.ca Article but there is a point that has been missed in the article:
You will still be able to talk on a phone in Ontario (and the law in Quebec allows this as well) if you have a bluetooth headset. That leaves both hands free but you are still talking on the phone.
Admittedly I have a cell phone (OK I may possess several but I only have 2 cell phone numbers - one for North America and one for Europe) and I do have a bluetooth headset. I rarely talk while driving as I normally use my phone for non-verbal communication (SMS or wireless data). I do not condone doing that while driving but I will admit to picking up my phone while waiting at my upteenth light on my way in to work to catch up with reading email and news. I would prefer a better public transit system so I could take that in to work and play (?work?) with my cell phone in safety but that is another matter altogether.
As to the consumer culture and consumerism of cell phones - the people that you see buying new phones every two years are ones that pick the cheap and trendy phones and they have to keep up with the Jones' and get new stuff. I have had my current phone (Nokia N95-4 8GB) since December 2008, and I was previously using a phone that my wife now has (Nokia N95-2 8GB) for the previous 9 months. We have invested in good quality phones that are not cheap but they are hard to throw away because they work well and will serve many purposes for many years.
thanks for the clarification
I knew I should have looked that up. Oddly enough, when I called 2 weeks ago to report a school bus driver who was jabbering away on a cell phone while driving a bus load of kids, the company did not correct me that it is not yet a law in Ontario. Though I do believe it has been their policy for some time.
Nonetheless, I think the guy this morning at least is a good poster child for why we need this law. Not that I haven't also seen people go through that light without the encumbrance of a cell phone. Caught a guy about 2 weeks ago and bumped into him about 3 minutes later on my street and pointed out to him how unimpressed I was. That guy was pretty smug about it all, and honestly if this were 3 or 4 years ago he'd probably be missing a few teeth right now.
My plan to counteract the bad drivers (cell phone or no)
Documentation !
I drive ~90 minutes every day, and see tons of bad drivers. I plan on mounting a video camera in my car and taping my trip, posting the nice ones to a you-tube like website ;-)
no kidding
I was thinking of doing something very similar - I'm sure I've seen sites like this out there
Economic Model
Maybe I could make enough on advertising on the site to get a new cell phone %rim shot%
They have a purpose
I'm issued one for work, so I haven't decided myself "self-important" enough to buy one. ;o)
I know I'm a schmo, but my boss apparently thinks I need to be reached anytime at all.
I'm actually a phone-o-phobe. I hate talking on the phone.
I have bought one for SWMBO however. and our daughter's daycare has both of our cell numbers.
In fact, the only numbers I answer immediately are SWMBO and daycare.
If my daughter had an accident at daycare and is heading to the hospital, I want to be there waiting when she arrives.
Probably the only reason I answer my SWMBO's calls immediately is in case she's hurt, or the daycare called her first. ;o)
If the datacenter is going up in flames, it can wait till I finish my supper/beer.
The nice thing about modern phones is you can select special ringers for certain numbers, or no ringer at all. My phone is usually completely silent unless my SWMBO or daycare calls, in which case it lets out a loud nasty "BRRRRING!". no annoying Britney Spears ringtones here. LOL
I do however appreciate the mobile computing capabilities.
Waiting in the car while the baby sleeps and Momma's running into the store to grab something, it's nice to read through the latest MoB news.
I would think that would attract you.
Have you told your new boss that you won't carry a mobile?
Hmmmm...the more I think about it.....
I was thinking about my comment "I'm issued one for work, so I haven't decided myself "self-important" enough to buy one. ;o)
I know I'm a schmo, but my boss apparently thinks I need to be reached anytime at all."
I guess I was saying that it seems my boss thinks I'm important enough to need to be reached at any time, but I think it may be more correct to say that the boss thinks herself important enough that I need to answer every beckon call...... yeah that makes more sense.
I try not to give in to fear
It is really surprising that someone who is as big a geek as me and so otherwise addicted to the Internet would not want one. But I try hard in my life not to give in to consumer "wants" vs "needs". When I give in to a want that is not a need, I'm feeding the machine.
As for kids and safety, I try REALLY hard not to give in to that fear, because I am EXTREMELY protective of my kids. But it is just an unsubstantiated fear - and I don't like to let my life be run by fear. Chances are very slim that if my child got hurt, there would be anything I could do about it - so having a phone on hand would not make any difference in their health. Sure, I could console my spouse a bit sooner than otherwise, but that is about it. But I like to be positive and hope that this will never happen.
Just the other day my oldest - 7 - asked for a cell phone! I could not believe it! This of course means that there must be friends of his at school who have them, because he certainly does not see his parents with one. I cannot believe that someone would give a 7 year old a cell phone! Brain cancer, anyone?
Many of the points you make of course prove that one does not have to let one's life be ruled by a cell phone, in the way I characterized in my initial article. And kudos to you for that! I knew when writing it that I was generalizing, and in fact I stated that several times.
I should have also stated explicitly to any of my (other) friends tuned in here, that I don't think any of you are bad people for owning cell phones - that would just be silly :-) Everyone makes their own choices. I've always been the type to root (route?) for the underdog or to take the other path. It lets you see things that most others either don't get to see, or take for granted.
Oh, and no, the topic did not come up during the interviews with my new employer. We shall see what transpires :-)
good points
I guess what I'm saying is that I like to think I'm very important to my family, in as much as they are important to me.
Obviously, I'm not saying that you don't care about your family as much as I care about mine because, I have a cell phone. LOL
If I lived downtown, I'd probably feel less necessity also, but with nearly an hour commute on dark country roads (a topic for further discussion later) I like having a backup. so far in the last 6 months, I've gone out to my clapped out old beater to find a dead battery twice, and ran out of gas on a country road once. I really appreciated having my phone those times.....would have appreciated it even more if SWMBO had answered her's.
;o)
Ugh....came in handy tonight
looks like the fuel pump is gone in my "free" car.
Had to call my wife AND a tow truck
$125 tow to get it home.
I could have bought a CAA membership for that.